what could of happen

[Slashist]

Axl is not gnr!

but his voice is unique and key to the gnr sound.  it wouldn't have worked, and I don't think that slash, duff or anyone would have ever tried to replace axl.  and whats the point of these crazy hypothetical questions in the GNR 2006 section?

[Bugaboo]

If Slash was replaceable, then Velvet Revolver wouldnt be this successful.
Furthermore, the very fact that Velvet Revolver has had this many hit singles so far, and a hit album only shows that Axl is the one who is replaceable.

Scott Weiland and promoters and poseur teenagers.

Had they chose and unkown singer (see Slash's Snakepit which had "original" drummer Matt Sorum as well and singer Eric Dover) they probly not do so well......

[Bugaboo]

Oh and Snakepit even had the bassist from aic  and still never were huge so huh! In your face! It is cuz promoters are sayin 3 members of GnR and Scott bitch ass Weiland- so they get some GnR some STP fans and some poseur teenagers and VOILA! you got a good fanbase!

[Gagarin]

Axl was the key to the band's sound.

Duh.  Think about it.

[adrian]

Oh and Snakepit even had the bassist from aic  and still never were huge so huh! In your face! It is cuz promoters are sayin 3 members of GnR and Scott bitch ass Weiland- so they get some GnR some STP fans and some poseur teenagers and VOILA! you got a good fanbase!

ok, and with new gnr, we get bumblefoot fans, we get NIN fans, we get GNR fans and new gnr isnt huge either and the only reason theyre selling any tickets is because of the name Guns N' Roses. And then we get little fanboys like yourself whod suck axls dick, and thats it, because you idiots are the only people stupid enough to support a band with a washed up lead singer, 3 guitarists, of which one is good, a decent keyboardist, a drummer that isnt even there,a crappy bassist, and some idiot that stands around pretending to do something, and NO single, NO cd, and songs from the 80s which only one of the members contributed to. What is your fuckin point? I know plenty of bands that arent huge but are fuckin good bands.

[ycagwyw]

ok, and with new gnr, we get bumblefoot fans, we get NIN fans, we get GNR fans and new gnr isnt huge either and the only reason theyre selling any tickets is because of the name Guns N' Roses. And then we get little fanboys like yourself whod suck axls dick, and thats it, because you idiots are the only people stupid enough to support a band with a washed up lead singer, 3 guitarists, of which one is good, a decent keyboardist, a drummer that isnt even there,a crappy bassist, and some idiot that stands around pretending to do something, and NO single, NO cd, and songs from the 80s which only one of the members contributed to. What is your fuckin point? I know plenty of bands that arent huge but are fuckin good bands.

I'm weird you're still here, fuck off !



finished

[adrian]

I'm weird you're still here, fuck off !



finished

...wtf?