What shouldn't be on chinese democracy

[Santa Clause]

Silkworms - just dumb

Better-  Worse than silkworms  irratating guitar tone , Cheesy Breakdown , Cheesy Lyrics , and he uses a little womans voice in the intro

madagascar- cheesy speach in the middle and too repetitive


the rest of the new songs are ok to put on CD.

[Santa Clause]

almost forgot

Rhyad and the whatever its called is bad to so i hope its on on cd

[Kov]

Better????


 :eek:

Are you out of your mind???  :eek:

[Santa Clause]

don't become the sheep  like the harley commercial and march to  better  just because it was thrown out at you its not all that great except for maybe his voice in certain areas but the rest is pretty dull.

[Jimmeh]

IRS - it's crap.

Rhiad would rock if done well in the studio.  Better is good enough, but IMO not the killer single we've been waiting for years for, ditto Chinese Democracy.  Madagascar is pretty good.

[Ponchibego]

Wowzers... you don't think madagascar should be on the album? That's one of my favorite songs... you seem to hate what everyone else likes.

[Santa Clause]

Wowzers... you don't think madagascar should be on the album? That's one of my favorite songs... you seem to hate what everyone else likes.

it would be alot better if they changed  the repetitive beat in the background that goes on for the whole song and got rid of the laughable mlk speach.

[Kov]

don't become the sheep  like the harley commercial and march to  better  just because it was thrown out at you its not all that great except for maybe his voice in certain areas but the rest is pretty dull.

No, look, I hate silkworms also, and Rhiad ain't too good either, but Better? I'm not being a sheep I actually like that song...

[Santa Clause]

No, look, I hate silkworms also, and Rhiad ain't too good either, but Better? I'm not being a sheep I actually like that song...

ok I actually like better slightly but  i don't want it to waste space on chinese democracy maybe robin fink & the rest of gnr should  just throw it out like SFTD.

[monom]

And really, these songs all suck don't they? I mean come on, the only reason we listen to them is the same reason as the baby penguins eat their mother puke, they all got thrown up at us. Fuck Axl...

Not really, Let 'em all be on CD, Rock on Axl, I know you're reading this goddamn it, stop sending me PMs every 4th minute.

[chineseroses]

Silkworms, rhyad, and IRS would be the ones id remove, remember madagascar is going to have proper orchestra on CD so that could change it completerly.

[Lucky]

IRS sucks.

[chineseroses]

IRS sucks.

if you would of said that a couple of months ago i would of disagreed but now its just boring and repetive, definatly shouldn't be on the album.

[Geck]

I'm not sure if I want to see IRS on the album or not. I really, really like it live, but I'm not sure if the final studio version will be that amazing. I dunno.