Which versions of the leaks would you put on Cd?

[AxlRoseCalifornia]

Me i would put : Better (the lighter version of HD)
                      Madagascar ( i would try to look for a better version of this one )
                      Chinese Democracy ( the 2007 version of it - live at the gibson amphitheatre)
                      Twat ( 1999 sessions leak )
                      IRS ( 1999 sessions leak )
                      The Blues ( the 2006/2007 version )

[Gunner_Fucker]

None of them exactly.
As for and IRS, I hope it doesn't make the album.

[cuddergnr]

irs owns

[misterbrownstone]

I.R.S. is sooo weak...gah.

as for the leaks, i only think the leak of Chinese is good enough for the album.  the others have some sound tweaking (or more, depending on the song) left.

[zombux]

I.R.S. is sooo weak...gah.

as for the leaks, i only think the leak of Chinese is good enough for the album.  the others have some sound tweaking (or more, depending on the song) left.

also the blues sound very "finished". IRS is great, just listen to Rock am Ring version.

[gokken]

IRS rocks! The best version is the one from 99.

[AxlRoseCalifornia]

IRS rocks! The best version is the one from 99.

i actually hate the rock am ring version, hate axl's voice on it.

I love the 99 version of the song. Its awesome!

[Randy Jesus]

None of the demos are properly mixed and mastered.

[Sweersa]

I.R.S. is sooo weak...gah.

as for the leaks, i only think the leak of Chinese is good enough for the album.  the others have some sound tweaking (or more, depending on the song) left.

IRS in my opinion is the weakest of the leaks but it is still an awesome song, it could use some work to push it up on the same level of coolness that the other leaks are at.

Axl sounds like an old man in the beginning of the Madagascar demo, then he seems himself later, which rocks.

[GnrJanus]

cd/end06-07.
Maddy 2002
Blues 06 and bonus blues 02.
Better.
I.r.s Rock am Ring style
Catcher
twat long version

[GGS]

I wouldn't put all the leaks on one CD cause it would just suck balls completely some the songs just don't mesh.

Obviously the newest Chinese Democracy version
Better
CITR
Maddy

is all i'd want to see together on the first CD personally then put

TWAT
Blues
Silkworms

On the second

IRS god just put it as a 'my world' kind of hidden track on the last cd or something.

[AxlRoseCalifornia]

Its funny, cause if uncle Axl reads this... he's gonna be nuts that people see IRS as an outro or a poor song. Its one of his favorites songs as he stated on one interview. 

Whatever is the final version, it can't be much different than the ones we already heard.
And the so called Rock am ring IRS, if you pay attention is exactly the same track as the IRS (99).
Listen to it closely and u'll see.

[axl_saves]

twat

[Gunner_Fucker]

he's gonna be nuts that people see IRS as an outro or a poor song.

Well, it is.
Deal with it Axl.

[JLR]

I think the songs need some tweaks but the majority are good enough for CD.

Songs that should be on CD:

Madagascar (With cleaner vocals)
The Blues (With less rasp in his voice)
TWAT (Chorus needs altering)
Better (Good enough as is although it could do without the fart noises)
Chinese Democracy (Good enough as is but I'd like the scream at the beginning to be better)

Other:

I.R.S. - A  good rocker but doesn't really fit with the rest of the songs.
CITR - A great song but probably won't be on CD
Silkworms - Live version sucked but an updated studio version could be awesome
Rhiad - same as Silkworms

[AxlRoseCalifornia]

I think the songs need some tweaks but the majority are good enough for CD.

Songs that should be on CD:

Madagascar (With cleaner vocals)
The Blues (With less rasp in his voice)
TWAT (Chorus needs altering)
Better (Good enough as is although it could do without the fart noises)
Chinese Democracy (Good enough as is but I'd like the scream at the beginning to be better)

Other:

I.R.S. - A  good rocker but doesn't really fit with the rest of the songs.
CITR - A great song but probably won't be on CD
Silkworms - Live version sucked but an updated studio version could be awesome
Rhiad - same as Silkworms

Fart noises 

[Bruno Poeys]

Whatever is the final version, it can't be much different than the ones we already heard.
And the so called Rock am ring IRS, if you pay attention is exactly the same track as the IRS (99).
Listen to it closely and u'll see.

But the '07 version is different. Ron's rhythm is different and his extended solo sounds awesome imo. Frank does an awesome job as well.

Better - '07 LIVE version
Chinese - '07 LIVE version (with the intro scream)
The Blues - same as the leak
Maddy - same as the leak, but with new vocals (Maybe with Fortus on lead? Dunno)
TWAT - '06 LIVE version
IRS - '07 LIVE version
Catcher - Axl has changed it for sure, but i love the demo
Rhiad - New vocals, less Pitman
Silkworms - New vocals, less Pitman (Axl probably has changed the song name and the song itself)

[Faxl]

They should add extra tom-tom to Prostitute, trust me.

[AxlRoseCalifornia]

how do u know? have u heard prostitute?