a funny trend with reviews for chinese democracy

[Xtap]

I love the vocals on Madagascar. They definitely fit the theme of the song, and I think it sounds right.

[DarrenLeves]

and what steal the other songs?
people need to grow up
we can think other  verisons are better
its like dont cry from UYI I
the demo is vastly superior
its not to say the final is not good
its just not as good as the other versions which is stupid since axl you would think would want to use the best version
CD is an 8/10 IMO but could have been a 9.5 or 10..0 if they did a few things different

How is it stealing 'other' songs?
 you have said that you have listenend to .... probably Downloaded the songs from the Offical release that is not out for another 7 days and you are comparing them to the Demo's of the songs from the offical release once again that you have listened to ... probably downloaded - it is too late for 'stealing' the songs surely?
 Like I said in my earlier post if you dont like the songs on the album dont buy it (and this is not aimed directly at you so please dont take it to heart). Save yourself some cash or buy someting that you will enjoy listening to.


 As for the UYI Demo's the majority of people heard them after the offical album came out (I know I did) that is totally differnt.

[rnbdesigners]

Funny I felt the same way about the Chinese Democracy single. At first I was like what is this crap. Now that I kept listing to it I love it.

[Justice_For_All28]

maybe he wanted in maddy to sound like this...he sounds tired ..so what maybe he wanted it that way...i personally think its perfect fit......if you dont like it, sing it yourself the way you like it.

Some ppl are never happy, i get a hard on listening to this stuff.

The record is versatile, takes chances...kills........

nothing i could say about metallica or ac/dc....
 

Wowzers you couldn't be more wrong if you tried. You've got yourself a point with Ac/Dc never taking chances... but Metallica? Have you followed their career what-so-ever? That's I suppose the thing I enjoy most about Metallica, is the fact that every album is different. You can't argue that any two are the same... Maybe Load and Reload. Metallica are anything but your typical Ac/Dc or Iron Maiden that find a formula that works and sticks with it album after album.