Is it safe to say....

[Tronx]

That -THIS I LOVE-  blows Dont Cry out of the water, in terms of emotions, sound, guitar solo? or do you think that dont cry still is better.

[seely]

This I Love blows LOADS of gnr songs out of the water, including Don't Cry!

[Reformed Terrorist]

they are different songs...

[aeroheadv1]

Both the songs are amazing in their own right.  It'd be like comparing Don't Cry Original to Alternate lyrics.  Though Alternate lyrics own pretty hardcore!  I think the alternate lyrics compare better to TIL, personally.  More of a fair fight, because Alternate lyrics have that most amazing third verse, and of course TIL with the fourth verse and the sustained "heart" lyric.

Either way I think we can all agree Axl continues to be the most amazing frontman out these days.

[Mickey Mouse]

That -THIS I LOVE-  blows Dont Cry out of the water, in terms of emotions, sound, guitar solo? or do you think that dont cry still is better.

And now i dont know why
this stupid thread wont die
Then it seems that i
Had semen in my eye

[seely]

 

[ShePoutsHerBest]

Dude, when it came out I really felt that This I Love pissed all over November Rain, Don't Cry s kinda a different comparison, but I don't know, I might like Don't Cry better, but I really see them as very different

[Bumbles N Roses]

And now i dont know why
this stupid thread wont die
Then it seems that i
Had semen in my eye

[Jigsaw]

Nowhere near, the lyrics are somewhat basic in comparison to Don't Cry, same with the solo.
In a way, its as if the song relies on Axl to sound like hes about to cry to give it that emotional feel.

[SuperMunkey]

I think it blows Don't Cry, definitely not Alt.Lyrics version of it though.

[eddierose0608]

i dont think they are even comparable total different vibe from both songs

[Iconic Shawn]

Dude what? No way..

Everyone who I show TIL to says Axl simply sounds like too much of a bitch in it.
Don't Cry was a great song. TIL is like whiny poetry.

~S~

[eddierose0608]

Dude what? No way..

Everyone who I show TIL to says Axl simply sounds like too much of a bitch in it.
Don't Cry was a great song. TIL is like whiny poetry.

~S~

do you just enjoy bitching about Axl and disagreeing with everyone?

[Iconic Shawn]

do you just enjoy bitching about Axl and disagreeing with everyone?

He asked a question and I answered it. I also said what others around me have thought about it.

Not everyone is going to like every song or share YOUR opinion. Its called an opinion. I noticed a lot of people live and die on that song. I think its because they're just as emotional as the song is so it hits them harder, which is fine.

I just don't happen to be that emotional. At least not when it comes to heart break. The lyrics honestly make me sick. He sounds pathetic in contrast to something like "TWAT" or "Better" which are pretty much about the same thing.

The solo is really good though and expresses the sentiment well.

~S~