is GN'R your favourite band of all time?

[seely]

What does the poll have to do with the question, by the way?

[alix-rose]

what?

[GNR_06]

Second favourite.
Miles behind Metallica!!

  

[RKD]

3rd.. it goes

1. Pink Floyd
2. Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers
3. Guns N' Roses

[©GnrPersia]

the only two things THESE TWO BANDS  share is the singer and the name.

yes and those 2 things means 70% of the old band of course in my opinion.

[White-Rider]

#1 for me.
You could say GN'R are my roots in music liking. 

spares me some effort. thanx.

[alix-rose]

yes and those 2 things means 70% of the old band of course in my opinion.

exactly. and my opinion is that nothing that doesn't have these two guys should be called Guns N' Roses. the new band is good. in fact it's awesome but it isn't GN'R except by the name.

-the music is different (it's good but different)
-the line-up is different (-||-)
-the feel is different.
- the band is different.

but of course that's just my opinion.

[aintitfun22]

guns n roses and against me! are my top 2.

[Dark Angel]

Nope

Bfoot
queen

[Bumbles N Roses]

For Me:

1. GN'R
2. Led Zeppelin
3. Metallica
4. New GN'R
5. Velvet Revolver (though Contraband is one of my favorite albums)
6. Skid Row
7. Lynyrd Skynyrd
8. Motley Crue
9. Queen
10. Shinedown
11. Megadeth

[loveshurt]

No. Queen is.

[alix-rose]

For Me:

1. GN'R
2. Led Zeppelin
3. Metallica
4. New GN'R
5. Velvet Revolver (though Contraband is one of my favorite albums)
6. Skid Row
7. Lynyrd Skynyrd
8. Motley Crue
9. Queen
10. Shinedown
11. Megadeth

very nice list.

mine is

1. GN'R
2. Aerosmith
3. Led Zeppelin
4. Corrosion Of Conformity
5. (95) Snakepit
6. Black Sabbath
7. VR
8. (2000) Snakepit
9. Rolling Stones
10. New GN'R
11. Blind Melon.
12.

Sign

(clickable)

[Ragamuffin]

No. Sentimentality will always put them up there simply because they were one of the metal bands that started me on the path to good music,gave me an appreciation for how meaningful sound can be,set off my interest in guitar, and built a bridge towards appreciating heavier,more complex metal/hard rock.I'm grateful/loyal and that's why I'm here. They aren't among my favourite bands currently at all though,I'll rarely listen to GnR anymore,maybe put on Nighttrain every now and then..Can't really comment on the new material as havent given it enough of a chance yet but it's not impressing me so far tbh.

[Bumbles N Roses]

very nice list.

mine is

1. GN'R
2. Aerosmith
3. Led Zeppelin
4. Corrosion Of Conformity
5. (95) Snakepit
6. Black Sabbath
7. VR
8. (2000) Snakepit
9. Rolling Stones
10. New GN'R
11. Blind Melon.
12. Sign (clickable)

You too.  I did not put Snakepit in though because I didnt wanna put in any side projects.