winnipeg gig review by rolling stone magazine and others

[antonyrose]

at the big-boy table we use words to discuss things. for the second time in two days, can i ask you to write with words rather than just smilies. posting only smilies is against the rules.

Okay, fine you want words?   That was my way of saying if anyone is spilling drivel it is you...  I noticed how you ignored my last post about people not realizing it was not the same gnr

[dman1991]

Somehow the thread went from positive magazine reviews to people criticizing the band, haters here?

[2NaFish]

Okay, fine you want words?   That was my way of saying if anyone is spilling drivel it is you... 

not that hard was it?

this has got to be the fourth or fifth time, but, in what way? try and make a reasoned response explaining why you think that.

[Tronx]

Somehow the thread went from positive magazine reviews to people criticizing the band, haters here?

yeah , agreed, lets focus on what the articles said and the reviews.........wich i think the band received great ones

[antonyrose]

I shouldn't have read the comments, there are some HUGE douchebags on there...

This is what started the argument, no one is bashing the band...

[antonyrose]

a couple? well bless my grits. thats thousands. congrats. you continue to prove the point i've been making all along. you're very helpful.

  You asked if I met people at a gnr gig and I did..  And you still gotta try and downplay it..   Here's to you..   

[Iconic Shawn]

^^^ What he said.

The band is doing good.

~S~

[Coma_Rose]

They had steak in 1991, what the fuck!

And for well over a decade now there's been a huge sign outside the restaurant saying 'NOW A TOFU RESTAURANT'

hahahaha

[Iconic Shawn]

haha..

Nope! They had a HUGE tarp over the establishment and renovated the place but forgot the mention they were going vegan only!

~S~

[dman1991]

haha..

Nope! They had a HUGE tarp over the establishment and renovated the place but forgot the mention they were going vegan only!

~S~

I hate tofu but I went in anyway just to tell everyone there how much better the place was in 1991, and how no matter what they think steak is better than tofu, and the restaurant will never be the same and they should change the name and location because people who ate there 20 years may come back and expect the same exact thing. They were all eager to hear about it....

Ok I think thats about as far as it can go, moving on!

[Phanatic]

2naFish is amazing... That argument is/was so full of win.

[antonyrose]

2naFish is amazing... That argument is/was so full of win.

I know, right??   

[Reformed Terrorist]

someone in a restaurant orders an expensive steak and gets tofu. how is that comparable to someone who doesnt go to a show and bitches on a comment board.

its fallacious as the new band is hardly comparable to tofu.
it's illogical as someone who doesnt go to the show wouldnt be the person in a restaurant. the person at a restaurant would be a fan at a gig.

do you not know what an analogy is? its not a matter of perception, you made an objectively weak analogy.

(once again) accept it and move on.

  consider my self your newest fan! lol i just wish i could speak such fluid english so that i could argue with you every now and then... as for now..  i'm stuck again with nothing