Review says, "Slash's solo album is miles better than Chinese Democracy."

[antonyrose]

Well ponder this, when GnR are eligiable for the rock n roll hall of fame who are they gonna induct? 

Axl
Slash
Duff
Steven/Matt
Izzy
and maybe Dizzy.   Not whoever is currently in Axl's band, and that IS A FACT

[Reformed Terrorist]

Ridiculous. 

[2NaFish]

Well ponder this, when GnR are eligiable for the rock n roll hall of fame who are they gonna induct? 

I'd imagine they will induct guns n' roses. Members of guns n' roses, past and present will be inducted, unless you plan on showing me something to counter this i cant understand why you've brought up this point that appears to disprove your argument.

However, once again you've created a worthless scenario. It doesnt matter who the HOF consider to be guns n' roses, the band that released CD is guns n' roses.

[Jesus_Of_Nazareth]

  Once again, you have gotten away from the original dispute.   Did you not see my above post?  Or are you blind as well as deluded.. When i'm wrong I admit it. According to Axl he did not buy it or force it and for that I admit I was wrong.   That being said, you always veer from the main point in any discussion and spin it to where you can spit facts that any one can look up online.   Bottom line no matter what you facts you have..  This is Axl's band, not Guns n Roses..  and that little man is A FACT.. You can fool yourself any way you want, but I know the fans know it Hell in his heart even Axl knows it.  Have a good wkend Tuna!!!   

you should really get over it.  making up your own false and UNfactual opinions as labeling them as fact is making you look foolish.

What year is this again?   Don't you have anything better to whine about than a silly band name?   If you don't like it, no one is making you stay a GnR fan.    Find something better to get worked up about.  This is stupid.

[Jesus_Of_Nazareth]

Well ponder this, when GnR are eligiable for the rock n roll hall of fame who are they gonna induct? 

Axl
Slash
Duff
Steven/Matt
Izzy
and maybe Dizzy.   Not whoever is currently in Axl's band, and that IS A FACT

Take note of who was inducted with Metallica and ask yourself how long people like Dizzy and Tommy have been in the band.    Going by the HoF's recent logic, just about anyone ever involved with GnR should be inducted.

[Reformed Terrorist]

I'd imagine they will induct guns n' roses. Members of guns n' roses, past and present will be inducted, unless you plan on showing me something to counter this i cant understand why you've brought up this point that appears to disprove your argument.

However, once again you've created a worthless scenario. It doesnt matter who the HOF consider to be guns n' roses, the band that released CD is guns n' roses.

I never thought of that... Axl, Slash, Izzy, Duff and Steven made famous the name "Guns N' Roses". I really don't know and don't care, but good point who ever mentioned it.

[antonyrose]

Take note of who was inducted with Metallica and ask yourself how long people like Dizzy and Tommy have been in the band.    Going by the HoF's recent logic, just about anyone ever involved with GnR should be inducted.

Since you decided to jump into a something you were not involved in.  If any of you truly think that any current revolving members of this band will be inducted into the hall of fame your fooling yourselves.. Wait and see....    Haha I can see it now according to you guys on the hall of fame stage will have..   Axl, Slash, Duff, Izzy, Steven, Matt, Gilby, Paul Huge, Richard, Buckethead, Bumblefoot, Robin, Brain, Frank Dizzy, Chris,Tommy, DJ.  Damn have I left anyone out.   

[2NaFish]

Since you decided to jump into a something you were not involved in.  If any of you truly think that any current revolving members of this band will be inducted into the hall of fame your fooling yourselves.. Wait and see....    Haha I can see it now according to you guys on the hall of fame stage will have..   Axl, Slash, Duff, Izzy, Steven, Matt, Gilby, Paul Huge, Richard, Buckethead, Bumblefoot, Robin, Brain, Frank Dizzy, Chris,Tommy, DJ.  Damn have I left anyone out.   

So, despite evidence to the contrary, you are continuing down this line.

[Chase the Ace]

CD is a Guns N'Roses album on paper. Not so much in spirit. Can we all just get over it. I still find it a great record.

[Jesus_Of_Nazareth]

Since you decided to jump into a something you were not involved in.

hey, if you don't want others involved in the discussion, try a PM.   post it on a public forum, and people will reply.  genius.

[madison]

Its hopeless. It boggles my mind that fans of 'Guns N' Roses' can't see past Axl's voice to see what a road of tragedy this bands reputation and respect level has driven through since the good old days.

It is what it is and thats fine,  but it was better, in fact, it was the best.

~S~

Ya, I know buddy.  I mean I like the new band and all thats why i'm here..  But man some of these tools actually believe that this band is the true Guns n Roses..   Such a shame...  I guess they forgot to realize that the reason there is this band at all is because of the original..    Members, albums, videos...   

Exactly. You both hit the nail on the head.

Anyone suggesting that the current lineup be included in any GNR HOF induction ceremony are either deluded, trolls, or extremely young kids who weren't around when GNR was the biggest band on the planet and therefore don't know what they missed.  It's quite hilarious to read some of these posts suggesting the revolving door of hired muisicans be included in the ceremony.  In fact, I would bet that if you asked DJ or any of the other hired hands if they felt they should be there, they would say no.

As for the name - this means nothing.  As I've said in the past - Axl could have bought the rights to the name "the Queen of England" - but that wouldn't make him the actual Queen of England.  Likewise, this current lineup is Axl's band - it's not GNR.

[Jesus_Of_Nazareth]

Anyone suggesting that the current lineup be included in any GNR HOF induction ceremony are either deluded, trolls, or extremely young kids who weren't around when GNR was the biggest band on the planet and therefore don't know what they missed.

Take a look at who was inducted with Metallica recently.  Their bass player was inducted before recording a single note with the band.    So if that guy gets inducted, you're right maybe DJ won't deserve it.. but surely guys like Tommy Stinson, Robin Finck, Buckethead, Dizzy Reed, Chris Pitman..  they stayed in the band for years, longer than many of the original guys and  damn right they deserve it because they are part of Guns N' Roses and Guns N Roses history.  And this is going by the HOF's own standards!  Some trolls they must be!

As for the name - this means nothing.  As I've said in the past - Axl could have bought the rights to the name "the Queen of England" - but that wouldn't make him the actual Queen of England.  Likewise, this current lineup is Axl's band - it's not GNR.

Axl didn't buy anything and he's been in Guns N' Roses since day one.   Buy a ticket to a show, it clearly Guns N' Roses on it.  Buy the album, it clearly says Guns N' Roses on it.  Those are facts.

Funny you never said deluded shit like this before Axl ripped you a new one.

[madison]

Funny you never said deluded shit like this before Axl ripped you a new one.

I never had to make such comments in the past because nobody was ever making such a ridiculous suggestion that every hired hand and backup singer should be part of the HOF ceremony before.  We banned trolls like you at the other place, and so we never had anyone making such ludicrous comments.  *shrugs*

[Jesus_Of_Nazareth]

madison, you need to learn how to fucking read.   instead you ignore all the valid points that were made to attack the messanger.   this is classic madsion, you twist shit around to fit your agenda.   EVERYONE knows this about you, and that you are a manipulative crazy old hag.

take a look at what i quoted where i said you never said deluded shit like this, had nothing to do with the HOF.    Try reading it again HON and maybe you can show me where I'm wrong.