Review says, "Slash's solo album is miles better than Chinese Democracy."

[gaby]

We banned trolls like you at the other place, and so we never had anyone making such ludicrous comments.  *shrugs*

I can't believe you are talking about trolls when I can see you trolling every thread I try to read in almost every forum. I'm trying to catch up with the GNR updates and what do I find? Your resentful posts everywhere - and you calling a troll anyone who dares to disagree with your opinion. I don't know if you realize how annoying you are

Some of the guys you call hired hands have been part of the band for more than a decade so nope I do not agree with what you said. I must be deluded, or a troll haha :p

[Jesus_Of_Nazareth]

I can't believe you are talking about trolls when I can see you trolling every thread I try to read in almost every forum. I'm trying to catch up with the GNR updates and what do I find? Your resentful posts everywhere - and you calling a troll anyone who dares to disagree with your opinion. I don't know if you realize how annoying you are

Some of the guys you call hired hands have been part of the band for more than a decade so nope I do not agree with what you said. I must be deluded, or a troll haha :p

Madison NEVER argues on the substance of the post.   She takes a piece here and combines it with a piece over there and makes up her own twisted interpetation of the post.   Shes ALWAYS done this, for many years.

For example, I even admit in my post folks like DJ might not be eligable.  And I never said Tracy and Roberta are going to be inducted so that takes away the backup singers.     Then I told her she never said deluded shit like "Its Axl's band not Guns N' Roses" in the past and she twists that into something about the HOF, ignoring all the very valid and legit points I made about both the HOF and the GnR name just to attack me.   She's truly a piece of work.

The real troll is Madison.   I've always thought the woman was a cancer to GnR sites and obviously Axl did too, it just took him a few more years to see it.  I'd assume she has some real issues with her social skills in the real world, so she comes to online fansites to troll people she disagrees with in her passive agressive madisony way.  Such a shame.

[antonyrose]

Exactly. You both hit the nail on the head.

Anyone suggesting that the current lineup be included in any GNR HOF induction ceremony are either deluded, trolls, or extremely young kids who weren't around when GNR was the biggest band on the planet and therefore don't know what they missed.  It's quite hilarious to read some of these posts suggesting the revolving door of hired muisicans be included in the ceremony.  In fact, I would bet that if you asked DJ or any of the other hired hands if they felt they should be there, they would say no.

As for the name - this means nothing.  As I've said in the past - Axl could have bought the rights to the name "the Queen of England" - but that wouldn't make him the actual Queen of England.  Likewise, this current lineup is Axl's band - it's not GNR.


[/quote]Wow, someone with sense!!! 

[mooney]

yeah, 'cause Maddy is definately the voice of reason around here...

[WillWallner]

I never had to make such comments in the past because nobody was ever making such a ridiculous suggestion that every hired hand and backup singer should be part of the HOF ceremony before.  We banned trolls like you at the other place, and so we never had anyone making such ludicrous comments.  *shrugs*

I think this sums it up completely. We must all try to realize how depressing it is to be a die hard fan for one of the biggest bands in the world. To love and support them your whole life - only to be insulted in front of the entire online fan community by the lead singer of that band. That's gonna make some deep emotional scars which is why your so anti new GNR and anti anyone who supports them. Hell hath no fury like a women scorned

[madison]

yeah, 'cause Maddy is definately the voice of reason around here...

I'm definitely the voice of reality.  I post what most people are thinking.  .
WillWallner - I've always spoken my mind and that certainly didn't change after Axl's rant.  I can't be bought or intimidated into censoring news or fan opinions. It's unfortunate that others don't have the same integrity and are afraid to express their honest opinions.  *shrugs*

[aintitfun22]

I'm definitely the voice of reality.  I post what most people are thinking.  .
WillWallner - I've always spoken my mind and that certainly didn't change after Axl's rant.  I can't be bought or intimidated into censoring news or fan opinions. It's unfortunate that others don't have the same integrity and are afraid to express their honest opinions.  *shrugs*

i agree with alot of the things you say, despite our differences over how you express it/the attitude with which you express it. Im not sure that what you post is what MOST people on here are thinking however. I  believe that while your opinions may be what MOST are thinking among old gnr fans, on chinesedemocracy.com you may not be in the majority as it was created as a new gnr board.

[Jesus_Of_Nazareth]

On topic.. No.  Slash's album in no way comes anywhere near Chinese D or any other Guns N' Roses effort.   

Thing about slash's album, it has a few good songs, but every single one of them has something very cheesy in it.    Chinese D was a stellar album that I still listen to a couple times a week.   I might listen to Ghost every now and then but thats its from the Slash album.   With that said, its all opinion.   The guy who wrote this review just has bad taste, but his opinion is no better than anyone else's.

[jamillos]

On topic.. No.  Slash's album in no way comes anywhere near Chinese D or any other Guns N' Roses effort.   

Thing about slash's album, it has a few good songs, but every single one of them has something very cheesy in it.    Chinese D was a stellar album that I still listen to a couple times a week.   I might listen to Ghost every now and then but thats its from the Slash album.   With that said, its all opinion.   The guy who wrote this review just has bad taste, but his opinion is no better than anyone else's.

well said

[UcudBmine]

this thread is entertaining

[Chase the Ace]

The guy who wrote this review just has bad taste

wow, oh really. That is a mouth full

not to say that Slash is better than CD, but to say someone has a bad taste, now really.

[mooney]

I'm definitely the voice of reality.

I'm a big fan of irony, too.

[Sean]

please easy with the insults in the GNR section and stay on topic

I'm definitely the voice of reality.  I post what most people are thinking.  .

Steven Adler Falls Out Of A Chair

[Ali]

please easy with the insults in the GNR section and stay on topic

Steven Adler Falls Out Of A Chair

Perfect response, Sean.

Ali